← Back to New York

Notch Lake Area Fishing Spots

20 Fishing Spots New York

With 20 documented fishing spots, the Notch Lake Area Fishing Spots stands as one of New York's premier angling regions. The zone boasts 15 scenic lakes and 5 trophy-producing reservoirs where Largemouth Bass, Catfish, and other popular gamefish thrive in healthy populations throughout the season.

This zone's proximity to multiple water types means anglers can plan multi-day trips targeting different species each day. Fishing is productive from April through October, with spring and fall offering the best action. The combination of access, fish diversity, and scenic beauty makes it a standout region.

For bass in this region, local anglers favor a mix of artificial lures and live bait depending on conditions. Soft plastics, crankbaits, and spinnerbaits consistently produce results across the lakes here. Bank anglers find success near points, fallen timber, and weed edges, while boaters often work deeper structure and drop-offs. Fly fishing enthusiasts will find opportunities on the moving water in this zone, particularly during spring and fall hatches.

The Notch Lake Area Fishing Spots is well-suited for both day trips and extended fishing vacations. With 20 spots to explore, you could spend weeks discovering new water in this zone alone. Budget-friendly camping and RV parks are scattered throughout the area, and many spots allow bank fishing without the need for a boat. Download the coordinates from our spot listings to program your GPS, and always verify current access conditions before heading to a new location.

All 20 Fishing Spots in This Zone

Lakes (15)

Beaver Lake

📍 41.8887, -74.2581
View on Maps ↗

Lake Paradise

📍 41.8425, -74.5998
View on Maps ↗

Lower Birch Creek Trailhead Pond

📍 42.1589, -74.4454
View on Maps ↗

Lyonsville Pond

📍 41.8544, -74.2159
View on Maps ↗

Mirror Lake

📍 41.9663, -74.5816
View on Maps ↗

Mirror Pond

📍 41.9787, -74.5757
View on Maps ↗

North Timber Lake

📍 42.1542, -74.3402
View on Maps ↗

Notch Lake

📍 42.1606, -74.2033
View on Maps ↗

Peekamoose Lake

📍 41.9268, -74.3762
View on Maps ↗

Pine Hill Lake

📍 42.1272, -74.4742
View on Maps ↗

Round Pond

📍 41.9390, -74.5857
View on Maps ↗

South Timber Lake

📍 42.1510, -74.3412
View on Maps ↗

Tunis Pond

📍 42.0183, -74.5617
View on Maps ↗

Vly Pond

📍 42.0236, -74.5780
View on Maps ↗

White Pond

📍 41.9780, -74.5180
View on Maps ↗

Reservoirs (5)

Beaverdam Pond

📍 41.8109, -74.5379
View on Maps ↗

Furlough Lake

📍 42.0708, -74.5663
View on Maps ↗

Lyonsville Pond

📍 41.8511, -74.2163
View on Maps ↗

Rondout Reservoir

📍 41.8301, -74.4757
View on Maps ↗

Winnisook Lake

📍 42.0144, -74.4126
View on Maps ↗

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes, a valid New York fishing license is required to fish at any location within this zone. Licenses can be purchased online through the New York wildlife agency or at local bait shops.

The Notch Lake Area Fishing Spots includes 20 documented fishing locations across New York. These range from small ponds and streams to large lakes, providing options for every skill level.

Fishing is productive from April through October, with spring and fall offering the best action. Water conditions, hatches, and fish behavior all vary by season, so checking recent local reports before your trip is always a good idea.

Anglers in this zone commonly target Largemouth Bass, Catfish, and Bluegill. Species availability varies by water body and season — check individual spot pages for specific species information.