← Back to New York

Lake Nelson Area Fishing Spots

25 Fishing Spots New York

With 25 documented fishing spots, the Lake Nelson Area Fishing Spots stands as one of New York's premier angling regions. The zone boasts 21 crystal-clear lakes and 4 trophy-producing reservoirs where Largemouth Bass, Catfish, and other popular gamefish thrive in healthy populations throughout the season.

The region's diverse aquatic habitats support robust fish populations year-round. Fishing is productive from April through October, with spring and fall offering the best action. Experienced guides in the area suggest adapting your approach based on seasonal patterns and water temperature changes.

The diverse fisheries in this zone reward anglers who adapt their approach. Start with moving baits like spinnerbaits or swim jigs to locate active fish, then switch to finesse presentations once you find a productive area. Shore access is available at many locations, making this zone ideal for wading anglers and those without boats. A basic setup with a spinning rod, size 6 hooks, and a selection of soft plastics can produce fish at nearly every spot in this zone.

Most fishing spots in the Lake Nelson Area Fishing Spots are accessible via paved roads, with many offering designated parking areas and clear trails to the water. Public boat ramps are available at the larger lakes, typically with no launch fee or a nominal daily charge. Several spots also have accessible fishing piers, making them suitable for anglers with mobility limitations. Cell service can be spotty in the more remote areas of this zone, so downloading offline maps before your trip is recommended.

All 25 Fishing Spots in This Zone

Lakes (21)

Abraham's Pond

📍 40.5409, -74.2316
View full guide →

Castle Point Pond

📍 40.5369, -74.4617
View on Maps ↗

Clay Pit Pond

📍 40.5432, -74.2289
View on Maps ↗

Connor's Pond

📍 40.5499, -74.3592
View on Maps ↗

Cunningham Pond

📍 40.5076, -74.2224
View on Maps ↗

Duck Pond

📍 40.5080, -74.5723
View on Maps ↗

Goode's Pond

📍 40.5419, -74.2254
View on Maps ↗

Lake Creighton

📍 40.5671, -74.5157
View on Maps ↗

Lake Nelson

📍 40.5411, -74.4427
View on Maps ↗

Lake Papaianni

📍 40.5247, -74.3997
View on Maps ↗

Long Pond

📍 40.5146, -74.2275
View on Maps ↗

Lucille Ball Pond

📍 40.5541, -74.3665
View on Maps ↗

Mettlers Pond

📍 40.5084, -74.5691
View on Maps ↗

Mount Loretto Pond

📍 40.5080, -74.2206
View on Maps ↗

Oak Tree Pond

📍 40.5765, -74.3753
View on Maps ↗

Powder Mill Pond

📍 40.5108, -74.5598
View on Maps ↗

Sharrotts Pond

📍 40.5345, -74.2263
View on Maps ↗

Spring Lake

📍 40.5842, -74.4123
View on Maps ↗

Tappan's Pond

📍 40.5436, -74.2246
View on Maps ↗

Tommy's Pond

📍 40.5357, -74.3634
View on Maps ↗

Village Pointe Pond

📍 40.5573, -74.3962
View on Maps ↗

Reservoirs (4)

Eastern Branch Reservoir

📍 40.5869, -74.5565
View on Maps ↗

New Market Pond

📍 40.5778, -74.4520
View on Maps ↗

Spooky Brook Pond

📍 40.5079, -74.5634
View on Maps ↗

Washington Valley Reservoir

📍 40.5929, -74.5671
View on Maps ↗

Frequently Asked Questions

Many of the larger lakes in this zone have public boat launches and ramp access. Shore fishing is also available at numerous locations. Check individual spot details for specific access information.

The Lake Nelson Area Fishing Spots includes 25 documented fishing locations across New York. These range from small ponds and streams to large lakes, providing options for every skill level.

Yes, a valid New York fishing license is required to fish at any location within this zone. Licenses can be purchased online through the New York wildlife agency or at local bait shops.

Anglers in this zone commonly target Largemouth Bass, Catfish, and Bluegill. Species availability varies by water body and season — check individual spot pages for specific species information.