← Back to New York

Gem Lake Area Fishing Spots

134 Fishing Spots New York

Covering a diverse stretch of New York, the Gem Lake Area Fishing Spots is home to 134 unique fishing locations. This area features 101 scenic lakes and 33 deep reservoirs, offering anglers the chance to target Largemouth Bass, Catfish, and other popular gamefish across varied habitats and conditions.

Fishing is productive from April through October, with spring and fall offering the best action. Local anglers recommend bringing a variety of tackle to match the diverse water conditions found throughout the zone. From shallow weedlines to deep structure, each waterway presents its own unique challenges and rewards.

Experienced anglers in New York recommend matching your technique to the specific water conditions in this zone. During warmer months, topwater action can be explosive at dawn and dusk on the lakes. As water temperatures drop, transitioning to slower presentations like jigs and drop-shot rigs produces consistent catches. Ice fishing is available during winter months in the northern portions, targeting panfish and walleye through the ice.

Planning a fishing trip to the Gem Lake Area Fishing Spots is straightforward thanks to its accessibility. Many spots are within a short drive of towns offering lodging, dining, and bait shops where you can pick up local intel. Camping is available near several of the larger water bodies for multi-day trips. Remember to check the New York fishing regulations for any special rules that may apply to specific waters in this zone, including slot limits, creel limits, and seasonal closures.

All 134 Fishing Spots in This Zone

Lakes (101)

Barrett Pond

📍 41.4340, -73.7404
View full guide →

Beaman Pond

📍 41.7324, -73.4020
View on Maps ↗

Brady Pond

📍 41.6007, -73.5323
View on Maps ↗

Brewster Pond

📍 41.4363, -73.5989
View on Maps ↗

Case Pond

📍 41.7843, -73.4609
View on Maps ↗

Chapel Pond

📍 41.7186, -73.5090
View on Maps ↗

Chapel Pond

📍 41.5412, -73.5192
View on Maps ↗

China Pond

📍 41.4417, -73.7434
View on Maps ↗

Christie Pond

📍 41.6626, -73.6738
View on Maps ↗

Clapboard Ridge Pond No 1

📍 41.4231, -73.4812
View on Maps ↗

Clapboard Ridge Pond No 2

📍 41.4236, -73.4816
View on Maps ↗

Corner Pond

📍 41.4420, -73.5255
View on Maps ↗

Crane Pond

📍 41.7438, -73.5347
View on Maps ↗

Day Camp Pond No 2

📍 41.4535, -73.4050
View on Maps ↗

Dean Pond

📍 41.4575, -73.6857
View on Maps ↗

Deer Pond

📍 41.5528, -73.5215
View on Maps ↗

Deer Pond

📍 41.5260, -73.5121
View on Maps ↗

Depression Pond

📍 41.7270, -73.5285
View on Maps ↗

Dickens Pond

📍 41.4102, -73.4951
View on Maps ↗

Disbrow Pond

📍 41.4665, -73.4745
View on Maps ↗

Dixon Lake

📍 41.4200, -73.7316
View on Maps ↗

Doyles Pond

📍 41.4211, -73.4491
View on Maps ↗

Eberle Pond

📍 41.4529, -73.4095
View on Maps ↗

Edmonds Pond

📍 41.6192, -73.4962
View on Maps ↗

Ellis Pond

📍 41.6806, -73.5468
View on Maps ↗

Emmadine Pond

📍 41.5656, -73.7938
View on Maps ↗

Farringtons Pond

📍 41.4040, -73.5386
View on Maps ↗

Feldman Pond

📍 41.4907, -73.4912
View on Maps ↗

Freedom Lake

📍 41.6970, -73.7701
View on Maps ↗

Fuller Pond

📍 41.7613, -73.4751
View on Maps ↗

Geer Mountain Pond

📍 41.7051, -73.4268
View on Maps ↗

Gem Lake

📍 41.5020, -73.7989
View on Maps ↗

Gerow Brook Pond

📍 41.4841, -73.5081
View on Maps ↗

Gillotti Pond

📍 41.4614, -73.4997
View on Maps ↗

Green Mountain Lake

📍 41.5782, -73.6051
View on Maps ↗

Green Pond

📍 41.5507, -73.4603
View on Maps ↗

Greenwood Pond

📍 41.5590, -73.5060
View on Maps ↗

Hatch Pond

📍 41.6845, -73.4781
View on Maps ↗

Haviland Millpond

📍 41.5577, -73.4723
View on Maps ↗

Heddons Pond

📍 41.6441, -73.4045
View on Maps ↗

Hillside Lake

📍 41.6177, -73.7977
View on Maps ↗

Ice Pond

📍 41.4549, -73.6130
View on Maps ↗

Indian Brook Pond

📍 41.4658, -73.7162
View on Maps ↗

Ironworks Road Pond

📍 41.4993, -73.4018
View on Maps ↗

Jennings Pond

📍 41.5466, -73.5122
View on Maps ↗

John Pond

📍 41.4911, -73.7752
View on Maps ↗

Jones Pond

📍 41.6247, -73.6233
View on Maps ↗

Kellners Pond

📍 41.4156, -73.4456
View on Maps ↗

Lake Carmel

📍 41.4599, -73.6647
View on Maps ↗

Lake Dutchess

📍 41.5173, -73.6725
View on Maps ↗

Lake Ossi

📍 41.4164, -73.7604
View on Maps ↗

Lake Tibet

📍 41.4525, -73.7794
View on Maps ↗

Lake Tonetta

📍 41.4210, -73.6110
View on Maps ↗

Lake Wackawana

📍 41.4118, -73.4605
View on Maps ↗

Leonard Pond

📍 41.7058, -73.4747
View on Maps ↗

Little Buck Mountain Pond

📍 41.4889, -73.7207
View on Maps ↗

Lockwood Pond

📍 41.4281, -73.7408
View on Maps ↗

Long Pond

📍 41.4096, -73.7323
View on Maps ↗

Lost Lake

📍 41.4562, -73.5472
View on Maps ↗

Manlapaz Pond

📍 41.4684, -73.4900
View on Maps ↗

Mendel Pond

📍 41.4803, -73.6032
View on Maps ↗

Merritts Pond

📍 41.5028, -73.5306
View on Maps ↗

Merryall Pond

📍 41.6455, -73.4389
View on Maps ↗

Mill Pond

📍 41.5126, -73.6852
View on Maps ↗

Moffit Pond

📍 41.7468, -73.7347
View on Maps ↗

Mud Pond

📍 41.6732, -73.4576
View on Maps ↗

Narrow Pond

📍 41.4880, -73.4823
View on Maps ↗

Newfield Pond

📍 41.6111, -73.4312
View on Maps ↗

Norris Pond

📍 41.7169, -73.6806
View on Maps ↗

North Spectacle Pond

📍 41.7303, -73.4179
View on Maps ↗

Palmer Lake

📍 41.4389, -73.6738
View on Maps ↗

Parce Pond

📍 41.5684, -73.6348
View on Maps ↗

Parkhurst Pond

📍 41.6237, -73.4218
View on Maps ↗

Pell Lake

📍 41.6589, -73.6287
View on Maps ↗

Pine Pond

📍 41.4656, -73.7078
View on Maps ↗

Pond Gut

📍 41.7238, -73.7562
View on Maps ↗

Quaker Pond

📍 41.5418, -73.5201
View on Maps ↗

Rogers Pond

📍 41.4062, -73.4830
View on Maps ↗

Rogers Pond

📍 41.5950, -73.4891
View on Maps ↗

Saw Mill Road Pond

📍 41.4612, -73.4750
View on Maps ↗

Scalzo Pond

📍 41.4501, -73.4207
View on Maps ↗

Seven Hills Lake

📍 41.4862, -73.7492
View on Maps ↗

Sharparoon Pond

📍 41.6805, -73.5939
View on Maps ↗

Smiths Pond

📍 41.4183, -73.4474
View on Maps ↗

South Spectacle Pond

📍 41.7174, -73.4184
View on Maps ↗

Sprout Lake

📍 41.7210, -73.7382
View on Maps ↗

Sterns Pond

📍 41.4338, -73.5054
View on Maps ↗

Strastrom Pond

📍 41.6435, -73.4065
View on Maps ↗

Sylvan Lake

📍 41.6091, -73.7420
View on Maps ↗

Tracy Pond

📍 41.5668, -73.5575
View on Maps ↗

Turtle Pond

📍 41.4057, -73.4789
View on Maps ↗

Twin Pond

📍 41.4822, -73.5244
View on Maps ↗

Upper Kohanza Lake

📍 41.4243, -73.4932
View on Maps ↗

Upper Peck Pond

📍 41.7982, -73.4597
View on Maps ↗

Valley Pond

📍 41.5289, -73.5083
View on Maps ↗

Wawayanda Lake

📍 41.4409, -73.7872
View on Maps ↗

White Pond

📍 41.5017, -73.7240
View on Maps ↗

Wimisink Pond

📍 41.6184, -73.5080
View on Maps ↗

Wolzles Pond

📍 41.7641, -73.4259
View on Maps ↗

Wonder Lake

📍 41.4900, -73.6480
View on Maps ↗

Zalesskys Pond

📍 41.6256, -73.4299
View on Maps ↗

Reservoirs (33)

Adams & White Pond

📍 41.6078, -73.4415
View full guide →

Blatz Pond

📍 41.7695, -73.4640
View on Maps ↗

Boggs Pond

📍 41.4178, -73.5307
View on Maps ↗

Boyd Corners Reservoir

📍 41.4598, -73.7487
View on Maps ↗

Deer Lake

📍 41.6351, -73.5564
View on Maps ↗

East Lake Reservoir

📍 41.4432, -73.4934
View on Maps ↗

Forest Lake

📍 41.4821, -73.4812
View on Maps ↗

Furnace Pond

📍 41.6427, -73.6966
View on Maps ↗

Great Mountain Pond

📍 41.5638, -73.4558
View on Maps ↗

Hilltop Pond

📍 41.7925, -73.4927
View on Maps ↗

Irvings Pond

📍 41.6965, -73.4430
View on Maps ↗

Jordan Pond

📍 41.7784, -73.4738
View on Maps ↗

Ladner Pond

📍 41.6081, -73.4356
View on Maps ↗

Lake Charles

📍 41.4521, -73.5705
View on Maps ↗

Lake Gleneida

📍 41.4204, -73.6841
View on Maps ↗

Lake Mauweehoo

📍 41.5397, -73.4984
View on Maps ↗

McKinney Pond

📍 41.6571, -73.6954
View on Maps ↗

Mercers Pond

📍 41.4027, -73.4767
View on Maps ↗

Merton Mill Pond

📍 41.4668, -73.5155
View on Maps ↗

Middle Branch Reservoir

📍 41.4047, -73.6443
View on Maps ↗

Mill Pond

📍 41.6755, -73.4699
View on Maps ↗

Padanaram Reservoir

📍 41.4331, -73.4842
View on Maps ↗

Patterson Reservoir

📍 41.5023, -73.5774
View on Maps ↗

Pawling Reservoir

📍 41.5760, -73.5756
View on Maps ↗

Platts Pond

📍 41.5355, -73.5011
View on Maps ↗

Pray Pond

📍 41.6792, -73.6775
View on Maps ↗

Richards Pond

📍 41.7650, -73.4630
View on Maps ↗

Spring Lake

📍 41.5905, -73.5107
View on Maps ↗

Sunset Lake

📍 41.5529, -73.6550
View on Maps ↗

Timber Lake

📍 41.5363, -73.5117
View on Maps ↗

West Branch Reservoir

📍 41.4358, -73.6934
View on Maps ↗

West Branch Reservoir

📍 41.4488, -73.6946
View on Maps ↗

Willow Lake

📍 41.5558, -73.6573
View on Maps ↗

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes, a valid New York fishing license is required to fish at any location within this zone. Licenses can be purchased online through the New York wildlife agency or at local bait shops.

The Gem Lake Area Fishing Spots includes 134 documented fishing locations across New York. These range from small ponds and streams to large lakes, providing options for every skill level.

Anglers in this zone commonly target Largemouth Bass, Catfish, and Bluegill. Species availability varies by water body and season — check individual spot pages for specific species information.

Fishing is productive from April through October, with spring and fall offering the best action. Water conditions, hatches, and fish behavior all vary by season, so checking recent local reports before your trip is always a good idea.