← Back to New York

Ice Lake Area Fishing Spots

135 Fishing Spots New York

With 135 documented fishing spots, the Ice Lake Area Fishing Spots stands as one of New York's premier angling regions. The zone boasts 110 expansive lakes, 24 well-managed reservoirs and one pristine river where Largemouth Bass, Catfish, and other popular gamefish thrive in healthy populations throughout the season.

What makes this zone special is the variety of fishing experiences available within a short drive. Fishing is productive from April through October, with spring and fall offering the best action. Whether you prefer fly fishing in moving water or casting topwater lures on a calm lake, this area has you covered.

Experienced anglers in New York recommend matching your technique to the specific water conditions in this zone. During warmer months, topwater action can be explosive at dawn and dusk on the lakes. As water temperatures drop, transitioning to slower presentations like jigs and drop-shot rigs produces consistent catches. Ice fishing is available during winter months in the northern portions, targeting panfish and walleye through the ice.

Planning a fishing trip to the Ice Lake Area Fishing Spots is straightforward thanks to its accessibility. Many spots are within a short drive of towns offering lodging, dining, and bait shops where you can pick up local intel. Camping is available near several of the larger water bodies for multi-day trips. Remember to check the New York fishing regulations for any special rules that may apply to specific waters in this zone, including slot limits, creel limits, and seasonal closures.

All 135 Fishing Spots in This Zone

Lakes (110)

Alpine Lake

📍 41.0774, -75.2850
View full guide →

Analomink Lake

📍 41.0622, -75.2272
View full guide →

Beaver Lake

📍 41.3918, -75.0904
View on Maps ↗

Beaver Pond

📍 41.2134, -75.1057
View on Maps ↗

Billings Pond

📍 41.3804, -75.0753
View on Maps ↗

Birch Lake

📍 41.1981, -75.2595
View on Maps ↗

Blue Mountain Lake

📍 41.0425, -75.1975
View on Maps ↗

Bluestone Pond

📍 41.3264, -75.0503
View on Maps ↗

Brookdale Lake

📍 41.0837, -75.3387
View on Maps ↗

Browns Lake

📍 41.2119, -75.1827
View on Maps ↗

Bruce Lake

📍 41.3508, -75.1709
View on Maps ↗

Camp Dora Golding Lake

📍 41.0542, -75.1482
View on Maps ↗

Camp Sun Mountain Lake

📍 41.0319, -75.1007
View on Maps ↗

Coolbaugh Lake

📍 41.0647, -75.0719
View on Maps ↗

Crescent Lake

📍 41.0717, -75.3866
View on Maps ↗

Deep Lake

📍 41.0525, -75.3966
View on Maps ↗

Deer Lake

📍 41.0574, -75.0986
View on Maps ↗

Deer Lake

📍 41.2042, -75.2818
View on Maps ↗

Dormoy Lake

📍 41.1686, -75.1916
View on Maps ↗

Eagle Lake

📍 41.0502, -75.1622
View on Maps ↗

Echo Lake

📍 41.0691, -75.0602
View on Maps ↗

Echo Lake

📍 41.1700, -75.3814
View on Maps ↗

Emerald Lake

📍 41.0730, -75.1301
View on Maps ↗

Fairview Lake

📍 41.3982, -75.1868
View on Maps ↗

Fairview Lake

📍 41.1170, -75.3661
View on Maps ↗

First Pond

📍 41.1358, -75.0272
View on Maps ↗

Freeland Pond

📍 41.0736, -75.2764
View on Maps ↗

Golden Pond

📍 41.3773, -75.2885
View on Maps ↗

Goose Pond

📍 41.2532, -75.1933
View on Maps ↗

Goose Pond

📍 41.2454, -75.1991
View on Maps ↗

Gravel Pond

📍 41.2276, -75.2553
View on Maps ↗

Hallowood Lake

📍 41.0959, -75.1935
View on Maps ↗

Hawkeye Pond

📍 41.1418, -75.3917
View on Maps ↗

Heron Pond

📍 41.3767, -75.2922
View on Maps ↗

Hiawatha Lake

📍 41.1268, -75.1807
View on Maps ↗

Hidden Lake

📍 41.0524, -75.0491
View on Maps ↗

Highland Lake

📍 41.0360, -75.2309
View on Maps ↗

Highwood Lake

📍 41.0581, -75.3037
View on Maps ↗

Hunter Lake

📍 41.0070, -75.3113
View on Maps ↗

Ice Lake

📍 41.1484, -75.2907
View on Maps ↗

Icks Pond

📍 41.2814, -75.2077
View on Maps ↗

Lake Ann

📍 41.1315, -75.1135
View on Maps ↗

Lake Belle

📍 41.2800, -75.1497
View on Maps ↗

Lake Carobeth

📍 41.1967, -75.3690
View on Maps ↗

Lake Crawford

📍 41.1118, -75.2683
View on Maps ↗

Lake Earnest

📍 41.2885, -75.1599
View on Maps ↗

Lake Jamie

📍 41.2421, -75.2869
View on Maps ↗

Lake Lackawac

📍 41.3821, -75.2914
View on Maps ↗

Lake Minausin

📍 41.0969, -75.3536
View on Maps ↗

Lake Minisink

📍 41.2159, -75.0531
View on Maps ↗

Lake Monroe

📍 41.1176, -75.1357
View on Maps ↗

Lake Scott

📍 41.3550, -75.1383
View on Maps ↗

Lake Tomico

📍 41.2121, -75.1996
View on Maps ↗

Lake Valhalla

📍 41.0336, -75.1691
View on Maps ↗

Lake in the Clouds

📍 41.2441, -75.2729
View on Maps ↗

Laurel Lake

📍 41.0197, -75.2815
View on Maps ↗

Leisure Lake

📍 41.0756, -75.3281
View on Maps ↗

Little Bell Pond

📍 41.3304, -75.0518
View on Maps ↗

Little Mud Pond

📍 41.3926, -75.0404
View on Maps ↗

Long Pond

📍 41.3542, -75.1609
View on Maps ↗

Lower Lake

📍 41.2281, -75.2348
View on Maps ↗

Lower Twin Lake

📍 41.0310, -75.2365
View on Maps ↗

Lynchwood Lake

📍 41.1480, -75.3893
View on Maps ↗

Manzanedo Lake

📍 41.1174, -75.1952
View on Maps ↗

Marshall Lake

📍 41.0462, -75.1206
View on Maps ↗

McConnell Pond

📍 41.3361, -75.0378
View on Maps ↗

Meadow Lake

📍 41.0631, -75.0900
View on Maps ↗

Memorytown Lake

📍 41.1228, -75.3216
View on Maps ↗

Mount Nebo Pond

📍 41.0340, -75.1131
View on Maps ↗

Mountain Lake

📍 41.2332, -75.2340
View on Maps ↗

Mountain Spring Lake

📍 41.0131, -75.3542
View on Maps ↗

Onawa Lake

📍 41.1733, -75.2783
View on Maps ↗

Otter Lake

📍 41.1411, -75.1567
View on Maps ↗

Piersons Pond

📍 41.3636, -75.0800
View on Maps ↗

Pine Lake

📍 41.3390, -75.2728
View on Maps ↗

Pocahontas Lake

📍 41.0535, -75.1989
View on Maps ↗

Pocono Highlands Lake

📍 41.0711, -75.1087
View on Maps ↗

Pocono Plateau Lake

📍 41.2344, -75.3047
View on Maps ↗

Pocono Summit Lake

📍 41.1221, -75.3844
View on Maps ↗

Rainbow Pond

📍 41.0388, -75.1111
View on Maps ↗

Rake Pond

📍 41.0609, -75.1043
View on Maps ↗

Ransberry Pond

📍 41.2214, -75.2042
View on Maps ↗

Rimrock Pond

📍 41.3189, -75.0463
View on Maps ↗

Rock Hill Pond

📍 41.3137, -75.0156
View on Maps ↗

Saddle Brook Pond

📍 41.3106, -75.0408
View on Maps ↗

Sean's Swamp Pond

📍 41.1506, -75.1655
View on Maps ↗

Shawnee Lake

📍 41.0264, -75.1014
View on Maps ↗

Spring Lake

📍 41.0119, -75.1593
View on Maps ↗

Spruce Cabin Pond

📍 41.1996, -75.2198
View on Maps ↗

Spruce Lake

📍 41.2251, -75.2707
View on Maps ↗

Summit Lake

📍 41.1197, -75.3900
View on Maps ↗

Sunfish Pond

📍 41.0030, -75.0737
View on Maps ↗

Sunset Lake

📍 41.1324, -75.3946
View on Maps ↗

Swiftwater Lake

📍 41.0977, -75.2773
View on Maps ↗

Tanglwood Lake

📍 41.3711, -75.2354
View on Maps ↗

Taylor Pond

📍 41.2410, -75.3300
View on Maps ↗

Third Pond

📍 41.1566, -75.0294
View on Maps ↗

Timothy Lake

📍 41.1150, -75.0655
View on Maps ↗

Trout Lake

📍 41.0045, -75.3388
View on Maps ↗

Twelve Mile Pond

📍 41.1790, -75.0929
View on Maps ↗

Upper Twin Lake

📍 41.0326, -75.2323
View on Maps ↗

Waynewood Lake

📍 41.3935, -75.3628
View on Maps ↗

Werry Lake

📍 41.0739, -75.0462
View on Maps ↗

Wigwam Lake

📍 41.0050, -75.2583
View on Maps ↗

Wilkinson Lake

📍 41.1916, -75.1694
View on Maps ↗

Wilson Creek Lake

📍 41.2933, -75.2377
View on Maps ↗

Wish for a Fish Pond

📍 41.3109, -75.0457
View on Maps ↗

Woodland Lake

📍 41.0748, -75.1813
View on Maps ↗

Wyler Lake

📍 41.3731, -75.1665
View on Maps ↗

Wynooska Lake

📍 41.2842, -75.2462
View on Maps ↗

Reservoirs (24)

Beaver Lake

📍 41.3925, -75.2829
View on Maps ↗

Camp William Penn Lake

📍 41.1508, -75.1484
View on Maps ↗

East Stroudsburg Reservoir

📍 41.0682, -75.1662
View on Maps ↗

Egypt Meadow Lake

📍 41.3518, -75.1933
View on Maps ↗

Elm Lake

📍 41.3234, -75.0614
View on Maps ↗

Flagler Reservoir

📍 41.0019, -75.2366
View on Maps ↗

Hemlock Lake

📍 41.3040, -75.0470
View on Maps ↗

Lake Giles

📍 41.3771, -75.0931
View on Maps ↗

Lake Laura

📍 41.2995, -75.1673
View on Maps ↗

Lake Paupack

📍 41.3245, -75.2597
View on Maps ↗

Lake Roger

📍 41.1192, -75.0816
View on Maps ↗

Lower Hemlock Lake

📍 41.2950, -75.0441
View on Maps ↗

Lower Lake

📍 41.3156, -75.2247
View on Maps ↗

Mill Brook Pond

📍 41.3692, -75.2003
View on Maps ↗

Mud Pond

📍 41.2743, -75.1862
View on Maps ↗

PA-463 Reservoir

📍 41.2095, -75.2459
View on Maps ↗

Pa-447 Reservoir

📍 41.2464, -75.3562
View on Maps ↗

Pa-464 Reservoir

📍 41.2077, -75.2369
View on Maps ↗

Panther Lake

📍 41.2598, -75.3141
View on Maps ↗

Place Pond

📍 41.1179, -75.0199
View on Maps ↗

Sambo Creek Lower Reservoir

📍 41.0433, -75.1824
View on Maps ↗

Saw Creek Pond

📍 41.1636, -75.0711
View on Maps ↗

Second Pond

📍 41.1471, -75.0301
View on Maps ↗

Siebecker Pond

📍 41.3171, -75.3588
View on Maps ↗

Rivers (1)

Kintz Creek Lake

📍 41.2796, -75.2296
View on Maps ↗

Frequently Asked Questions

Fishing is productive from April through October, with spring and fall offering the best action. Water conditions, hatches, and fish behavior all vary by season, so checking recent local reports before your trip is always a good idea.

Anglers in this zone commonly target Largemouth Bass, Catfish, and Bluegill. Species availability varies by water body and season — check individual spot pages for specific species information.

Yes, a valid New York fishing license is required to fish at any location within this zone. Licenses can be purchased online through the New York wildlife agency or at local bait shops.

Many of the larger lakes in this zone have public boat launches and ramp access. Shore fishing is also available at numerous locations. Check individual spot details for specific access information.