← Back to New York

Elda Lake Area Fishing Spots

57 Fishing Spots New York

The Elda Lake Area Fishing Spots in New York encompasses 57 fishing destinations, including 40 legendary lakes and 17 abundant reservoirs. Anglers visiting this region can expect productive waters holding Largemouth Bass, Catfish, and other popular gamefish, with opportunities ranging from quiet shore fishing to adventurous boat outings.

What makes this zone special is the variety of fishing experiences available within a short drive. Fishing is productive from April through October, with spring and fall offering the best action. Whether you prefer fly fishing in moving water or casting topwater lures on a calm lake, this area has you covered.

For bass in this region, local anglers favor a mix of artificial lures and live bait depending on conditions. Soft plastics, crankbaits, and spinnerbaits consistently produce results across the lakes here. Bank anglers find success near points, fallen timber, and weed edges, while boaters often work deeper structure and drop-offs. Fly fishing enthusiasts will find opportunities on the moving water in this zone, particularly during spring and fall hatches.

Access to the fishing waters in this zone is generally very good, with a mix of public lands, state wildlife areas, and municipal parks providing entry points. Be aware that some smaller waters may be surrounded by private property — always verify access rights and look for posted signs. The best local advice comes from nearby bait shops, where staff can point you toward the current hot bite and steer you away from areas that are unfishable due to low water or other seasonal conditions.

All 57 Fishing Spots in This Zone

Lakes (40)

Blanchard Lake

📍 40.9233, -73.3383
View on Maps ↗

Charles Pond

📍 40.8661, -73.0077
View on Maps ↗

Dixie Pond

📍 40.7280, -73.1805
View on Maps ↗

Duck Pond

📍 40.9270, -73.3893
View on Maps ↗

East Pond

📍 40.7374, -73.0915
View on Maps ↗

Elda Lake

📍 40.7254, -73.3288
View on Maps ↗

Fellers Pond

📍 40.6917, -73.3733
View on Maps ↗

Fishermans Wharf Lake

📍 40.7039, -73.3409
View on Maps ↗

Fishermans Wharf Pond

📍 40.7039, -73.3399
View on Maps ↗

Frog Pond

📍 40.9130, -73.1479
View on Maps ↗

Fuchs Pond

📍 40.9153, -73.3315
View on Maps ↗

Gibbs Pond

📍 40.8450, -73.1394
View on Maps ↗

Gould Pond

📍 40.8491, -73.1204
View on Maps ↗

Harrison Pond

📍 40.8916, -73.2295
View on Maps ↗

Hawleys Lake

📍 40.6989, -73.3166
View on Maps ↗

Judges Pond

📍 40.8511, -73.1841
View on Maps ↗

Lake Ronkonkoma

📍 40.8273, -73.1228
View on Maps ↗

Lotus Lake

📍 40.7456, -73.0659
View on Maps ↗

Lower Winganhauppauge Lake

📍 40.7259, -73.2032
View on Maps ↗

Mill Lake

📍 40.7497, -73.0683
View on Maps ↗

Mill Pond

📍 40.8905, -73.3711
View on Maps ↗

Millers Pond

📍 40.8474, -73.1939
View on Maps ↗

Mooney Pond

📍 40.8344, -73.0906
View on Maps ↗

O-co-nee Lake

📍 40.7184, -73.2578
View on Maps ↗

Orowoc Lake

📍 40.7292, -73.2249
View on Maps ↗

Phillips Millpond

📍 40.8558, -73.2151
View on Maps ↗

Roe Pond

📍 40.7546, -73.0349
View on Maps ↗

Romano Pond

📍 40.8595, -73.0102
View on Maps ↗

Roth Pond

📍 40.9117, -73.1238
View on Maps ↗

Setauket Lake

📍 40.9434, -73.1163
View on Maps ↗

Slade Pond

📍 40.7532, -73.1363
View on Maps ↗

Southards Pond

📍 40.7111, -73.3284
View on Maps ↗

Spectacle Pond

📍 40.8343, -73.1343
View on Maps ↗

Spectacle Pond

📍 40.8360, -73.1345
View on Maps ↗

Town Hall Pond

📍 40.7056, -73.3738
View on Maps ↗

Twin Ponds

📍 40.8840, -73.3612
View on Maps ↗

Upper Winganhauppauge Lake

📍 40.7288, -73.2028
View on Maps ↗

West Pond

📍 40.7368, -73.0926
View on Maps ↗

Willow Pond

📍 40.8520, -73.2271
View on Maps ↗

Wyandanch Spring Lake

📍 40.7534, -73.3507
View on Maps ↗

Reservoirs (17)

Canaan Lake

📍 40.7883, -73.0209
View on Maps ↗

East Pond

📍 40.7494, -73.1436
View on Maps ↗

Great Patchogue Lake

📍 40.7762, -73.0227
View on Maps ↗

Great Patchogue Lake

📍 40.7709, -73.0214
View on Maps ↗

Lower Cascade Lake

📍 40.7119, -73.2609
View on Maps ↗

Lower Pond

📍 40.7490, -73.1500
View on Maps ↗

Main Pond

📍 40.7528, -73.1479
View on Maps ↗

Mill Pond

📍 40.7446, -73.0759
View on Maps ↗

Mirror Lake

📍 40.7146, -73.2626
View on Maps ↗

Sanford Lake

📍 40.7308, -73.2467
View on Maps ↗

Sans Souci Lakes

📍 40.7541, -73.0603
View on Maps ↗

Sans Souci Lakes

📍 40.7497, -73.0624
View on Maps ↗

Sans Souci Lakes

📍 40.7586, -73.0599
View on Maps ↗

Setauket Mill Pond

📍 40.9463, -73.1156
View on Maps ↗

Upper Cascade Lake

📍 40.7140, -73.2638
View on Maps ↗

West Brook Pond

📍 40.7467, -73.1565
View on Maps ↗

West Lake

📍 40.7649, -73.0280
View on Maps ↗

Frequently Asked Questions

Anglers in this zone commonly target Largemouth Bass, Catfish, and Bluegill. Species availability varies by water body and season — check individual spot pages for specific species information.

Fishing is productive from April through October, with spring and fall offering the best action. Water conditions, hatches, and fish behavior all vary by season, so checking recent local reports before your trip is always a good idea.

Many of the larger lakes in this zone have public boat launches and ramp access. Shore fishing is also available at numerous locations. Check individual spot details for specific access information.

The Elda Lake Area Fishing Spots includes 57 documented fishing locations across New York. These range from small ponds and streams to large lakes, providing options for every skill level.